Results 1 to 4 of 4
 0 Attachment(s)    

Thread: Difference between STP and ECN brokers

  1. #1
    Senior Member fxtester's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    3,165

    Default Difference between STP and ECN brokers

    An interesting answer.

    Chief Market Strategist, Forex Trader, Technical & Fundamental Analyst, Fund & Asset Management

    Choosing a broker isn't that easy. There are hundreds of brokers out there with their mission to scam you! Before investing check for feedback on the website Forex Peace Army or surf some forums. It's very hard to find a broker that will satisfy all your needs like spread, no slippage, deposit amount etc. but overall, you need to know if you want to trade with a Market Maker (MM), TRUE STP or an ECN broker.

    So let's say a few words about those three types of brokers.

    Market Maker - like the name already says, this broker makes the market. This means that every time you buy or sell a pair the broker is the counter party. If you lose your money, this means that the broker earns it. So you can see that their interest is you losing money and that's bad. The only good thing is the instant execution, all your orders are filled almost in the same second and you won't get any re-quotes. This type of brokers are OK for smaller amounts but when you'll start making trades at 5$/pip they will delay your execution or even make your trades re-quote. But on the other hand, market maker have account types with minimal deposit requirements and often offer nice welcome bonuses for newbie trades. Some will give you 5$, 10$ and up to 200$ bonus without any deposit made, other have some nice bonuses on deposit up to 50%, check out here for at Free Forex Bonus

    ECN Broker is a broker that offers you direct trading on the real market. This broker makes money from spread displayed to you: let's say if the current real spread on an GBPUSD pair is 0.3 pips, this broker might display you a 0.6 pips spread, so he's making 0.3 pips on every trade you make. And ECN brokers have commissions per round turn lot traded, around 10$/round lot. Real ECN brokers have min deposits above 1k$ and min lotsize of 1$/pip. Some ECN brokers can even offer you 0 pip spreads! But like mentioned for a small trader ECN execution is often beyond reach: because its interbanking nature, traders are typically required to trade very large lots and minimum deposit requirements are somewhere from $50,000 to $100,000. This model is also responsible for all the re-quotes and order rejections because when you open a large order the broker routes it to the real market, but the prices there might have already changed so the broker is faced with two options: either rejecting the order asking for you to adjust prices or completing the order by taking the risk that it might end up a successful trade meaning the broker will have to pay you from its pockets and this will not happen.

    STP Brokers are a hybrid between Market Makers and ECN brokers. This type of broker displays most of the time its own quotes which are correlated to the actual inter banking quotes.
    And now here is the real complexity of STP brokers: This brokers sometimes routes your orders to the real market (acts as an STP broker) but other times it doesn't and acts like a Market Maker.
    STP brokers use complex algorithms that finds if a trader is successful and automatically routes those traders to the real market while small and losing traders aren't routed to the market. This way the broker profits twice: once by clients losses and another by not losing money to successful traders. STP brokers are currently a hit and are not so long around.

    Personally I would choose to trade with a TRUE STP broker that routes all my traded directly to the market, but the whole point of this group is to hear all alternative opinions and logical arguments based on facts.
    Difference between Market Maker, ECN and STP broker | LinkedIn

  2. #2
    Banned
    Join Date
    Nov 2014
    Posts
    61

    Default

    An Electronic Communications Network (ECN) refers to the system that the broker is using in order to receive quotes and transfer orders.
    in short, ECN system collects buy and sell quotes from liquidity providers and then presents the best quotes available without considering the source. In other words, an ECN broker simply provides the trader with a trading platform and then acts as a middle man between the buyers and the sellers. I prefer to use ECN brokers, been years
    using Armada Markets, my account goes with their ECN trading account type, has a speed of execution and low spreads i've got 0.8 pips cost per trade with EURUSD, including commision.

  3. #3

    Default

    Brokers that provide comfort and safety in trading is an option trader. for this case, We must be selective in choosing a broker, make sure that the broker that we use to have clear regulations and have a good response to all customer complaints. And the most important is to have a good reputation .To ensure that brokers we use secure then we should use the minimum deposit offered by the broker to deposit as well as look at the performance and the length of time deposits and withdrawals. I saw it before using TenkoFx broker with more funds to open a PAMM ECN account with a minimum deposit of $ 100. I am also now using MT4 to trade using ECN PAMM account in TenkoFx. open a PAMM account at a broker is very easy

  4. #4
    Banned
    Join Date
    Mar 2015
    Posts
    136

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by paketrok View Post
    Brokers that provide comfort and safety in trading is an option trader. for this case, We must be selective in choosing a broker, make sure that the broker that we use to have clear regulations and have a good response to all customer complaints. And the most important is to have a good reputation .To ensure that brokers we use secure then we should use the minimum deposit offered by the broker to deposit as well as look at the performance and the length of time deposits and withdrawals. I saw it before using TenkoFx broker with more funds to open a PAMM ECN account with a minimum deposit of $ 100. I am also now using MT4 to trade using ECN PAMM account in TenkoFx. open a PAMM account at a broker is very easy
    I quite argee with you. Use minimum deposit which is enough for checking every option you need (for me it is at least 100$) and trade with a broker for a while. This rule is not about brokers, that require a big initial deposit, but there are just a few of them. Some brokers like Freshforex don't require any initial deposit.

Similar Threads

  1. Difference between Winners and Losers
    By painofhell in forum Trading discussion
    Replies: 19
    Last Post: 05-26-2017, 10:50
  2. Difference between the real and back test
    By torumegumi in forum Ideas for expert advisors
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 06-07-2013, 03:09
  3. Looking for something difference EA like this Article
    By zalinarashid in forum Ideas for expert advisors
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 09-07-2010, 15:49
  4. ODL: 5 Decimal instead of 4, Difference using EA
    By 823 in forum Expert advisors live statements
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 05-28-2009, 18:12
  5. Difference between demo and real
    By Mamounforex in forum Expert advisors backtesting
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 05-28-2009, 10:32

Tags for this Thread

100, algorithms, broker, brokers, deposit, ecn, eurusd, forex, forex trader, free, fundamental, gbpusd, low, money, offer, pips, real, slippage, spread, system, time, trader, trading, trading platform

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •